Assessment

How your injury is assessed, and why it decides so much

Underneath most questions in a New South Wales motor accident claim sits a medical one. What your injury is called, and how it is measured, decides what is paid, for how long, and whether a damages claim is open to you at all.

General information, not legal advice. This page sets out how the law generally applies. It does not take account of your circumstances, and you should get advice about your own situation before acting on it. The official sources this page is written from are listed on it; where they differ from anything here, they are the authority.

Last updated: 23 September 2026

Most people expect a motor accident claim to turn on who was at fault. Often it turns instead on two medical findings: whether the injury is a threshold injury, and what degree of permanent impairment it has caused. The insurer makes the first call on both. If you disagree, the question can go to an independent medical assessor appointed by the Personal Injury Commission, and what that assessor certifies binds you and the insurer alike.

Two findings, and what each one controls

The Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (NSW), which governs accidents on or after 1 December 2017, sorts injuries in a way that has less to do with how much they hurt than most people assume.

A threshold injury is defined in section 1.6 of the Act as a soft tissue injury, or a psychological or psychiatric injury that is not a recognised psychiatric illness. That definition is subject to the rest of the section, which sets out what counts as a soft tissue injury and what is carved out of it.

The classification carries a long way. Sections 3.11 and 3.28 bring weekly payments and statutory benefits to an end at a fixed point for people whose injuries are threshold injuries, and for injured adults who were most at fault. Section 4.4 is headed No damages for threshold injuries, and says what the heading says.

Degree of permanent impairment is the second finding. It is a percentage worked out under published guidelines rather than at large, and the Personal Injury Commission publishes the guidelines its assessors use for evaluating permanent impairment in compulsory third party disputes. It matters because damages for non-economic loss — the part usually described as pain and suffering — are available only where the degree of permanent impairment is above the threshold the Act sets. Below that line there is no award under that head, however real the pain.

The periods in sections 3.11 and 3.28 are written into the Act, and they are not the same for every benefit or every claimant. Take them from the Act itself or from SIRA rather than from any website, including this one.

The words changed in 2023

Until 1 April 2023 the Act called this category a minor injury. The Motor Accident Injuries Amendment Act 2022 (NSW) replaced the term with threshold injury and rewrote section 1.6 to match.

The change matters for reading rather than for worrying. If an insurer’s letter, an older form or an older page on a government site says minor injury, it is describing the same gateway. If you are holding a letter from 2021 next to one from this year, expect the language to differ and the question to be the same.

Which scheme your accident falls under

Two motor accident schemes run side by side in New South Wales, divided by the date of the accident. The Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 applies to accidents on or after 1 December 2017. The Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 applies to accidents that happened on or before 30 November 2017, and the Commission describes its permanent impairment guidelines for that scheme as covering accidents from 5 October 1999.

The Personal Injury Commission runs separate dispute pathways for each. Before anything else on this page applies to you, check the accident date against those ranges. The terminology, the assessment process and the entitlements are not the same in the two schemes, and material written about one is misleading if read against the other.

How the scheme works sets out the sequence a claim moves through.

Who decides a medical dispute

A medical dispute goes to the Personal Injury Commission, an independent statutory tribunal established by the Personal Injury Commission Act 2020 (NSW). Its Motor Accidents Division deals with motor accident matters, and medical questions travel down what the Commission calls the medical disputes pathway.

The Commission sets out the medical decisions of an insurer that a claimant can dispute:

Two of those have pages of their own: treatment and care disputes and income support disputes.

Internal review first, with one exception

As a general rule a medical dispute cannot be referred to the Commission until the insurer has carried out an internal review of the decision you disagree with, or has declined to conduct one, or has failed to complete one and notify you of the outcome when it was required to do so.

There is an exception worth knowing about. A medical dispute about the degree of permanent impairment does not have to go through internal review first. That was inserted into section 7.19 of the Act by the 2022 amendments.

Where internal review does apply, it is the step that starts the clock on everything after it. Ask for it in writing, and write down the date you asked.

Time limits apply both to asking an insurer for an internal review and to going to the Commission afterwards, and they are short. They run from dates on documents you were sent, so the document in your hand decides them rather than any general rule. Check them against the Act and the Commission’s own guidance, and get advice before one of them passes.

What a medical assessment involves

If a medical dispute is referred for assessment, the Commission appoints a medical assessor: an independent medical specialist accredited to assess injuries of the kind in dispute. Assessors are engaged directly by the Commission and are independent of claimants and insurers. The Commission selects the assessor; neither side nominates one.

Before the appointment the assessor reads what both parties have lodged. That includes reports from doctors who examined you at your lawyer’s request or at the insurer’s, reports from the practitioners treating you, your own statement, and investigations such as X-rays, MRIs, ultrasounds and CT scans.

At the appointment the assessor will usually examine you, and will ask how the injury happened, what it has done to you, what treatment you have had, and about your medical history including earlier injuries. Assessments are held at locations across New South Wales, and may be conducted by video where that is appropriate.

Two practical points. A medical assessor is not there to treat you and does not give advice or recommend treatment. And the insurer is required to meet the reasonable costs of your attending the assessment.

What is already in the medical records tends to weigh more than anything said on the day. That is the practical reason the early weeks are worth getting right — see what to do in the first weeks after an accident.

The certificate, and how binding it is

The assessor issues a medical assessment certificate setting out the decision on the issues in dispute and the reasons for it. On those issues the certificate is final and binding on the parties.

This is the part that is regularly underestimated. A certificate about threshold injury, or about the degree of permanent impairment, is not one opinion to be weighed against others later in the claim. It settles the question, and the entitlements that depend on that question follow from it.

If the certificate is wrong

There are two routes, and they answer different complaints.

A review by a medical review panel is open to either party, but only on the ground that the assessment was incorrect in a material respect, and the application has to say why. The President of the Commission then considers it, and the matter is referred to a panel only if the President is satisfied there is reasonable cause to suspect that the assessment was incorrect in a material respect. A panel is a Commission member and two medical assessors, and the assessor whose assessment is under review does not sit on it. The panel considers all aspects of the assessment afresh, and may confirm the original certificate or issue a new one in its place.

A further medical assessment is a different thing. It is available on the ground that the injury has deteriorated, or that additional information about the injury has emerged. It can be applied for at any time, but the matter may be referred for a further assessment only once by each party.

The window for applying for a panel review is short, and it runs from the date the certificate was sent to the parties by the Commission. If a certificate has arrived and you believe it is wrong, the date on the covering document is what to act on. When a decision goes against you puts this in the wider context.

Where the assessment leads, and where to get help

The assessment feeds straight into the rest of the claim. Whether the injury is a threshold injury bears on how long statutory benefits continue and on whether a claim for damages is open at all. The degree of permanent impairment bears on whether damages for non-economic loss are available. Damages claims deals with what follows.

If an assessment is in front of you now, there are places to ask questions that are not the insurer. SIRA operates CTP Assist, which gives information about motor accident claims and about the CTP Legal Advisory Service. LawAccess NSW is a New South Wales government service providing legal information and referrals. The Law Society of New South Wales operates a solicitor referral service for people looking for a lawyer.

None of that replaces advice on your own claim from an Australian legal practitioner who has read your documents and your dates.

Official sources