When the insurer says someone was at fault
What a liability decision actually decides, what it changes about your claim, and what can be done about one you think is wrong.
General information, not legal advice. This page sets out how the law generally applies. It does not take account of your circumstances, and you should get advice about your own situation before acting on it. The official sources this page is written from are listed on it; where they differ from anything here, they are the authority.
Last updated: 23 September 2026
A letter arrives from the CTP insurer saying it has made a decision on liability. It may say the accident was not its insured driver’s fault. It may say it was partly yours, or mostly yours. It is a short letter about a long word, and most people reading one for the first time assume it ends the claim.
Usually it does not. Liability in the New South Wales motor accident scheme is not one question with one answer. It is several separate questions, decided at different times, and some of them do not affect the early part of a claim at all. This page sets out which is which, and what happens to a liability decision you disagree with.
What a liability decision is
In this scheme the CTP insurer is the first decision-maker. When it decides liability it is deciding who, in its view, caused the accident: whether its own insured driver was at fault, whether you were, and whether anyone else was.
That decision is made in writing, and the written notice is the document that matters. It should say what was decided, give reasons for it, and tell you what you can do if you disagree. Keep it, and write on it the date it actually reached you rather than the date printed at the top. Several of the steps that follow run from the day you were notified.
If you are not sure what stage your claim is at, how the scheme works sets out the sequence a claim moves through.
Fault is not the first question, and it is not the only one
The most common misunderstanding about this scheme is that fault decides everything from the start. It does not. Statutory benefits for treatment, care and lost earnings are payable for an initial period without regard to who was at fault, which is why a claim is worth lodging even where you believe the accident was your own doing.
Fault becomes decisive after that. Once the early period ends, whether payments continue can turn on the liability decision, and a finding that you were at fault, or partly at fault, can reduce or end an entitlement that was not affected by it before.
Fault is also not the same question as injury. Whether your injury is what the Act calls a threshold injury, and what degree of permanent impairment it has caused, are medical questions decided by medical assessors, not by the liability decision. A claim can survive an adverse liability decision and fail on the medical findings, or the other way round.
Statutory benefits deals with what is payable while a claim runs; assessment of injury deals with the medical findings.
Partly at fault, mostly at fault, and a serious driving offence
Where the insurer says you contributed to the accident, that is contributory negligence. It is not an all-or-nothing finding. It is expressed as a proportion, and its effect is to reduce what is payable rather than to remove it.
There is a separate and blunter question of whether the accident was mostly caused by you. That is a different test from contributory negligence and it carries different consequences, and the two are often confused in the same letter.
There is also a distinct ground on which an insurer may refuse to pay statutory benefits where a claimant has committed a serious driving offence. If a letter refers to one, or if criminal proceedings are on foot arising out of the same accident, that is a point at which advice matters, because what is said in one process can be used in the other.
- Whether the accident was caused by someone other than you.
- Whether the accident was mostly caused by you.
- Whether statutory benefits can be reduced for contributory negligence once the initial period has passed.
- Whether the insurer may refuse payment because of a serious driving offence.
- Whether the accident is a no-fault motor accident under the Act.
Those are among the questions the Personal Injury Commission decides as a miscellaneous claim, which is the pathway most liability disputes take.
When the vehicle cannot be identified, or was not insured
A claim is made against the CTP insurer of a vehicle. Where the vehicle that caused the accident was never identified, or carried no insurance, the claim goes instead through the Nominal Defendant.
That route carries a requirement of its own. Whether due enquiry and search was made to establish the identity of the vehicle is a question the Commission can be asked to decide, and it is judged on what you did and when you did it. Write down now what you tried, who you asked and on what date. It is much easier to record than to reconstruct.
Which insurer a claim belongs to is itself a question that can be determined in the same pathway, so a dispute between insurers about who carries the claim is not something you have to resolve yourself.
What to do in the first weeks after an accident covers identifying the vehicle and the insurer in practical terms.
The first step is asking the insurer to look again
Before a liability dispute can be taken to the Personal Injury Commission, the decision generally has to have been through an internal review by the insurer. The Commission is explicit that a miscellaneous claims application requires the decision to have been the subject of an internal review, and it says more broadly that in some cases you are required to have an internal review from the insurer before you can lodge a dispute.
Internal review is asked for from the insurer, not from the Commission. Ask in writing, say plainly which decision you are asking to be reviewed, and record the date you asked. New material is worth sending with the request: a police fact sheet, a witness name, dashcam footage, a statement that corrects something recorded when you were in pain or on medication.
It is a genuine step rather than a formality. Some decisions change at internal review, and the ones that do not are usually better explained the second time.
When a decision goes against you follows the sequence through from the letter to the lodgement.
Who decides a liability dispute
Liability disputes about statutory benefits are dealt with by the Personal Injury Commission, an independent tribunal established by the Personal Injury Commission Act 2020 (NSW), rather than by a court in the first instance. The pathway is called miscellaneous claims assessment, and the questions it covers are the liability and procedural ones listed above, along with matters such as whether a claim was made in time and whether a full and satisfactory explanation has been given for non-compliance.
A member of the Commission determines the dispute, and the Commission states that a member’s decision on a miscellaneous claims matter relating to a claim for statutory benefits is binding on the parties. That cuts both ways: it binds the insurer, and it binds you.
This is a different pathway from the ones that deal with money and medicine. A dispute about an entitlement to statutory benefits goes to merit review, decided by a merit reviewer appointed by the President of the Commission rather than by a member. A dispute about the injury itself goes to a medical assessor. Lodging in the wrong pathway costs time, so it is worth being clear about which question you are actually disputing.
- Miscellaneous claims assessment - liability and the procedural questions that go with it.
- Merit review - entitlements to statutory benefits, such as weekly payments and expenses.
- Medical dispute - threshold injury, permanent impairment, and whether treatment is reasonable and necessary.
Applications are lodged through the Commission’s online Pathway Portal, and the Commission states that its dispute resolution services, including medical assessments, are free. A merit reviewer’s decision can itself be referred to a panel for review if it is said to be wrong in a material respect.
Liability in a damages claim is a separate question again
A claim for damages is a common law claim. It requires fault on someone else’s part and it is open only in some claims, so liability matters to it in a more direct way than it does to statutory benefits.
Where a damages claim is disputed it is usually assessed by the Commission rather than by a court. In that pathway the Commission states that the member must make a determination on the issue of liability and specify the amount of damages, so liability and quantum are decided together rather than in sequence. The parties are expected to use their best endeavours to settle the claim before it is referred for assessment.
Not every claim can be assessed that way. The Commission lists claims involving issues of liability, including contributory negligence, fault and causation, among the matters that may make a claim unsuitable for assessment. Where a claim is exempt, the Division Head issues a certificate of exemption and court proceedings have to be commenced within the timeframes the legislation sets. That is the point at which a claim stops being a tribunal matter and becomes litigation, and it is not a step to take on your own reading of a letter.
Damages claims takes this stream on its own.
Dates, and why no number appears here
Asking for an internal review, lodging a dispute with the Commission, asking for a panel review and commencing court proceedings after a certificate of exemption each carry a period of their own. They are short, they are not the same period as one another, and several of them run from the date you were notified of a decision rather than from the date of the accident.
That is why no count of days, weeks or months appears on this page. Which period binds you turns on the kind of claim, on the decision involved and on what your own papers say. The document you were given is what decides it, and a figure copied from a website is the wrong way to work out a date you are relying on.
Being late is not always fatal. The Act makes room for a claim made out of time where there is a full and satisfactory explanation for the delay, and whether an explanation qualifies is itself a question the Commission can decide. It remains far better not to need one. If a date may be close, say so first rather than waiting for an appointment.
Take the periods from the Act itself, from the State Insurance Regulatory Authority or from the Commission, with your own documents in front of you, and get advice before one of them passes.
What to have ready, and where to ask
A liability question is decided on documents more than on argument, and most of the useful documents exist within days of the accident.
There are places to ask that have no stake in the answer. The State Insurance Regulatory Authority regulates this scheme and publishes information for people making claims. LawAccess NSW is a New South Wales government service providing free legal information and referrals. The Law Society of New South Wales runs a solicitor referral service and a register that lets you check whether anyone advising you holds a current practising certificate.
None of that is a substitute for advice on your own claim from an Australian legal practitioner who has read your documents and your dates. Many motor accident claims are dealt with without a lawyer. Whether a disputed liability decision is one of them depends on what the decision says and on what turns on it. If you would rather describe the situation than read about it, tell us what has happened.
- The insurer's liability notice, with the date it reached you written on it.
- The police event number, and the fact sheet if you have been given one.
- The registration number of the other vehicle, and anything you did to identify it.
- Names and contact details of any witnesses.
- Dashcam or CCTV footage, before it is overwritten.
- Anything you have already sent the insurer, and the date you sent it.
Official sources
- Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (NSW)
- Personal Injury Commission Act 2020 (NSW)
- Personal Injury Commission of New South Wales
- Personal Injury Commission — motor accidents disputes, 2017 scheme
- Personal Injury Commission — miscellaneous claims assessment
- Personal Injury Commission — merit review dispute
- Personal Injury Commission — claims for damages assessment
- Personal Injury Commission — lodge a dispute
- State Insurance Regulatory Authority (NSW)
- SIRA — motor crash compensation
- LawAccess NSW
- The Law Society of New South Wales