Guide

When a decision goes against you

An insurer’s decision on a motor accident claim is usually not the last word. This guide sets out what can be disputed, who decides it, and the step that has to come first.

General information, not legal advice. This page sets out how the law generally applies. It does not take account of your circumstances, and you should get advice about your own situation before acting on it. The official sources this page is written from are listed on it; where they differ from anything here, they are the authority.

In short

An insurer’s decision about your claim can generally be disputed. For most decisions the first step is asking the insurer to review its own decision; if you still disagree, the matter goes to the Personal Injury Commission rather than to a court.

Find the letter that told you the decision and note the date it reached you. The periods for disputing run from that date and they are short.

What you have, and what comes first

An insurer administering a claim under the New South Wales motor accident injury scheme makes its decisions in writing and gives reasons. That letter is the document everything below turns on: keep it, and note the date it reached you.

For most disputes the Commission cannot look at a decision until the insurer has looked at it again. That step is an internal review: the insurer reconsidering its own decision. It is required before an application for merit review, before a miscellaneous claims assessment, and before a medical dispute, with one exception — a decision about the degree of permanent impairment does not have to go through it first.

Ask in writing, identify the decision, and keep a copy. Internal review is not an appeal to anyone independent, and if the answer does not change the pathways below are what comes next.

This guide describes the scheme under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (NSW), for accidents on or after 1 December 2017. An earlier Act covers accidents before that date, with separate dispute pathways — see assessment of injury.

Which pathway a dispute takes

The Commission sorts motor accident disputes by the kind of question in issue, and working out which pathway a disagreement belongs to is most of the work of lodging it.

Dates, and why no day count appears here

Every step has a period attached: asking for an internal review, applying to the Commission afterwards, and applying to review what the Commission decides. The periods are short, and most run from the date on a document you were sent.

No day count is printed on this site. What applies to you depends on which scheme the accident falls under, on the kind of decision, and on what the covering letter says. Take your dates from your own documents and have them checked.

Being late is not automatically the end of a matter, but it is not safe: an application made outside the period set for it is one the Commission does not have to accept. If a date is close, say so at the start when you ask anyone for help.

If the Commission's decision is the problem

A decision of the Commission is not reopened because a party is unhappy with it. The review routes are narrow, and whether any is open in your matter is a question for a lawyer who has read the decision.

A review by a panel is available where the decision is said to be incorrect in a material respect, and the application has to say why. The President refers it to a panel only if satisfied there is reasonable cause to suspect that. The route exists for a merit reviewer’s decision and for a medical assessment certificate.

A further medical assessment is different: available where the injury has deteriorated or further relevant information has emerged, it may be sought at any time, and a matter may be referred for one only once by each party.

Lodging a dispute, and where to ask

Applications are lodged through the Commission’s online Pathway Portal, and offline forms are available where lodging online is not possible. The Commission states that its dispute resolution services, including medical assessments, are free, and that it can arrange an interpreter at no cost.

The Commission will assist with the procedural aspects of an application but says it cannot give legal advice. The State Insurance Regulatory Authority regulates the compulsory third party scheme and publishes guidance for claimants, including through its CTP Assist service.

Where a claimant is not represented by an Australian legal practitioner, a settlement of a damages claim may be referred to the Commission for approval.

What usually happens

01

The decision arrives

The insurer notifies its decision in writing, with reasons. Keep the letter and note the date it reached you.

02

You ask for an internal review

In writing: identify the decision, say what is wrong with it, and note the date you sent it.

03

The insurer reviews its own decision

It may confirm or change the decision. It may also decline to review, or fail to complete one in time, and both matter for what comes next.

04

The dispute goes to the Commission

An application is lodged through the Pathway Portal in the pathway matching the question in dispute.

05

A decision, and a narrow right of review

A merit reviewer, medical assessor or Commission member decides, with reasons. A panel review is open only where the decision is said to be incorrect in a material respect.

Common questions

Do I have to accept the insurer's internal review decision?

No. Internal review is the insurer reconsidering its own decision. If the answer does not change, you can apply to the Personal Injury Commission in the pathway that matches the decision.

Can I dispute a decision without a lawyer?

Yes. Applications are lodged by claimants as well as by representatives, and the Commission says it can assist with the procedural aspects of an application, although it cannot give legal advice.

Does disputing a decision cost anything?

The Commission states that its dispute resolution services, including medical assessments, are free. What a lawyer may charge in this scheme is regulated and restricted, so ask for it in writing before anything begins.

My accident was before December 2017 — does this apply?

Not directly. An earlier Act governs those accidents and the Commission runs separate dispute pathways for them. The terminology and the entitlements are not the same, so check the accident date first.

Related

Before you ring anyone

Almost nothing about a dispute can be answered without the documents. Have the decision letter and the date it reached you, the claim number, everything else the insurer has sent, and the names of the practitioners treating you.

Official sources