Treatment and care

When the insurer will not pay for your treatment

What the insurer is deciding when it declines treatment, what a refusal should tell you, and how that decision is reviewed and then disputed.

General information, not legal advice. This page sets out how the law generally applies. It does not take account of your circumstances, and you should get advice about your own situation before acting on it. The official sources this page is written from are listed on it; where they differ from anything here, they are the authority.

Last updated: 23 September 2026

A physiotherapist recommends a course of treatment. A surgeon recommends an operation. It goes to the insurer and the answer is no, or for weeks it is nothing at all. This is one of the most common problems in the scheme, and there is a defined way out of it.

The way out has two steps. Ask the insurer to look at its own decision again, and then take it to the Personal Injury Commission as a medical dispute. Both steps have dates attached, and both are worth starting early.

What the insurer is actually deciding

Treatment and care are paid under the scheme where the treatment is reasonable and necessary in the circumstances, and where it relates to the injury caused by the accident. Those are the two tests, and almost every refusal rests on one of them.

The first is about the treatment itself: whether it is appropriate, whether it is likely to help, and whether it is the right treatment for this injury at this stage.

The second is about causation: whether the condition being treated was caused by the accident, or existed before it. Refusals on this ground often follow the insurer obtaining your earlier medical records, which is one reason those records matter so much.

A refusal is a decision about a request, not a judgment about you. It is also not permanent. A request declined at one stage can be made again when the clinical picture has changed.

What a refusal should tell you

A decision to decline or partly decline treatment has to be given to you in writing, and that written notice is the document everything after it runs from.

It should say what was declined, give the reasons, identify the material the insurer relied on, and tell you how to ask for an internal review. If any of that is missing, ask for it in writing rather than over the phone.

Then keep the notice, and write on it the date it actually reached you.

Ask for an internal review first

An internal review is the insurer looking at its own decision again, carried out by someone who was not the original decision-maker.

As a general rule a treatment dispute cannot be referred to the Personal Injury Commission until internal review has happened, or the insurer has declined to conduct one, or has failed to complete one and tell you the outcome when it was required to.

Ask in writing. Identify the decision, give its date, and say why you disagree. New material is worth attaching: a fresh report from the practitioner who recommended the treatment, imaging that was not available before, or a letter setting out what the treatment is expected to achieve.

The period for asking for an internal review, and the period for going to the Commission afterwards, are the periods the Act sets, which your insurer must tell you. They are short, and they run from dates printed on documents you were sent.

A medical dispute in the Commission

If the refusal survives internal review, the question goes to the Personal Injury Commission as a medical dispute. Whether treatment or care is reasonable and necessary in the circumstances, and whether it relates to the injury caused by the accident, are expressly among the medical decisions of an insurer that a claimant can dispute there. So is whether the treatment or care provided will improve your recovery.

The Commission is an independent tribunal established by the Personal Injury Commission Act 2020 (NSW). Applications are lodged through its online portal, and it publishes alternative arrangements for people who are not represented and cannot use it.

It is not a court and the process is not a hearing in the ordinary sense. A medical dispute is decided by a medical practitioner rather than argued in front of a judge.

Who decides it, and what the certificate does

A medical dispute is decided by a medical assessor: an independent medical specialist appointed by the Commission. Neither you nor the insurer nominates one.

The assessor reads what both sides have lodged, will usually examine you, and then issues a medical assessment certificate setting out the decision and the reasons for it. On the issues it covers, that certificate is binding on both parties.

Which is why what gets lodged matters so much. A report from the practitioner who actually recommended the treatment, saying plainly why it is necessary and what it is expected to achieve, does more work than a general letter of support.

Assessment of injury sets out what a medical assessment involves, what to expect at the appointment, and the two routes available if a certificate turns out to be wrong.

While the dispute is running

Try not to stop treatment. A gap in the record is read afterwards as a gap in the injury, and it is difficult to explain away even when the real reason was that nobody would pay for it.

Ask the practitioner treating you what is available in the meantime. Speak to your general practitioner about what Medicare covers, and check whether private health insurance helps. Some practitioners will treat and wait for the outcome if you explain the position.

Keep every receipt for anything you pay yourself. If the decision is overturned, reimbursement is worked out from that record.

Tell the practitioner what has happened. A treating doctor who knows the treatment has been refused can record the clinical need for it clearly, which is exactly the material a review turns on.

If the injuries are catastrophic

Where an injury is very severe, treatment and care may be funded outside the ordinary claim altogether. icare administers the Lifetime Care and Support Scheme, which funds treatment, rehabilitation and attendant care for people severely injured in a motor accident in New South Wales, for as long as it is needed and regardless of who was at fault.

Entry is decided against published criteria. If the injury is a spinal cord injury, a severe brain injury, an amputation, severe burns or blindness caused by a motor accident, ask about it early rather than waiting for the claim to run its course.

Where to ask

SIRA regulates this scheme, and its CTP Assist service gives information about motor accident claims and about the CTP Legal Advisory Service. It can also arrange an interpreter.

LawAccess NSW provides free legal information and referrals. The Law Society of New South Wales runs a solicitor referral service and a register where you can check that anyone advising you holds a current practising certificate.

None of that is advice about your own claim. That takes someone who has read your documents, your medical records and your dates.

Official sources