Damages

Damages: the part of a claim that turns on fault

Statutory benefits are paid while a claim is running, and in the early period they do not depend on who caused the accident. Damages are separate. They turn on fault, the Act limits them, and two findings about your injury usually have to be made before the question of money is reached at all.

General information, not legal advice. This page sets out how the law generally applies. It does not take account of your circumstances, and you should get advice about your own situation before acting on it. The official sources this page is written from are listed on it; where they differ from anything here, they are the authority.

Last updated: 23 September 2026

Most of what a motor accident claim delivers in its early months is statutory benefits: treatment, care and income support, paid by the insurer under the scheme rather than won from anybody. A claim for damages is a different proposition. It is a claim that someone else’s fault caused your injury and that you should be compensated for what the injury has cost you and will go on costing you. It opens later than statutory benefits, and it is not available to everyone who has been hurt.

Three different things, and only one of them is damages

It is worth separating them first, because people are often told they have a claim without being told which one.

Statutory benefits are the payments the scheme makes while a claim is on foot: treatment and care, and income support if you cannot work. In the early period they do not depend on fault, which is why they can start before anyone has decided who caused the accident.

Lifetime Care is for people who have been severely injured. icare, which administers it, describes the Lifetime Care and Support Scheme as paying for treatment, rehabilitation and care for people severely injured in a motor accident in New South Wales, and says it is a no-fault scheme: support is provided regardless of who was at fault, where the accident and the injury meet the criteria in the legislation. It is not a damages claim and not an alternative to one.

Damages are a lump sum, assessed once, for a loss caused by someone else’s fault. What an award may include is set by the Act rather than by general law, so a motor accident damages claim is narrower than the common law claim people often have in mind.

How the scheme works sets out the sequence a claim moves through, and where damages sit in it.

Which scheme your accident falls under

New South Wales has run two motor accident schemes, divided by the date of the accident. The Personal Injury Commission states that accidents on or before 30 November 2017 fall under the 1999 scheme, and accidents on or after 1 December 2017 under the 2017 scheme.

That is not a technicality. The two schemes differ on when damages are available, on terminology, and on the dispute pathways at the Commission. Material written about one misleads if it is read against the other, including this page, which is written about the 2017 scheme.

Two findings decide whether damages are open at all

Before the size of a claim is argued, the Act asks two medical questions, and the answers can close the door.

The first is whether the injury is a threshold injury. The Act bars an award of damages where it is. The insurer makes the first call; if that is disputed, the question is decided by an independent medical assessor appointed by the Commission, and the certificate binds both sides.

The second is the degree of permanent impairment, worked out as a percentage under published guidelines rather than at large. Damages for non-economic loss, the part usually described as pain and suffering, are available only where that percentage is above the threshold the Act sets. Below the line there is no award under that head, however real the pain. No percentage is printed here on purpose: take it from the Act or from the regulator, not from a website.

Because both questions are medical, what is in the records tends to decide more than anything argued later.

Assessment of injury deals with how these findings are made and what can be done about a certificate you believe is wrong. What to do in the first weeks after an accident covers the records.

Fault, and being partly responsible

A damages claim has to establish fault. Statutory benefits can be paid without that question being answered; damages cannot.

Being partly responsible does not necessarily end a claim, but it reduces one. Where the injured person’s own conduct contributed to the injury or to the harm that followed, an award can be cut back for contributory negligence, and not wearing a seatbelt or travelling with a driver affected by alcohol are the examples raised most often. The Act deals with this specifically, so the size of a reduction is not simply at large.

An insurer’s view about fault is a decision, made in writing, and a decision can usually be disputed. It is worth working out which of the insurer’s letters is the decision, because the steps that follow run from it.

Liability decisions deals with what a finding on fault affects and how one is challenged. When a decision goes against you covers the wider pattern.

Where a damages claim is assessed

Damages claims under the 2017 scheme do not start in a court. They go to the Personal Injury Commission, an independent statutory tribunal. The Commission states that a claim for damages may be lodged with it by the claimant, the insurer or both, and its Procedural Direction MA7 states that a claim for damages may be referred for assessment at any time.

The Commission expects the parties to have tried first: an application asks what best endeavours were used to settle the claim before referring it. A referral is the step after negotiation, not instead of it.

A registered matter is allocated to a pathway and, for a damages assessment, listed with a member. Most begin with a preliminary conference by video, which the member leads to identify what is actually in dispute, and the Commission says a high proportion of disputes are resolved there. If not, the matter may go to an assessment conference, where the member hears evidence from the claimant and any witnesses. Where the parties still cannot agree, the member determines the dispute and the Commission issues a Certificate of Determination setting out the decision and the reasons for it.

When a damages claim leaves the Commission for a court

Not every damages claim is assessed by the Commission. Some are exempted. The Commission’s Procedural Direction MA5 cites section 7.34(1)(a) of the Act and clause 14 of the Motor Accident Injuries Regulation 2017 for the mandatory route: a claim is exempt if it is of a kind the Regulation specifies. The discretionary route is section 7.34(1)(b), where a member determines that the claim is not suitable for assessment and the President agrees.

Once a certificate of exemption issues, the claim moves to a court, and the Commission’s guidance is blunt about what follows: court proceedings will need to be commenced within timeframes set out in the legislation. That is a hard edge, and one of the places where a claim can be lost on a date rather than on its merits.

The court is usually the District Court of New South Wales, which states that its civil jurisdiction covers all motor accident cases, irrespective of the amount claimed. The monetary limit on its other civil claims does not apply to these.

An exemption changes the timetable, not only the venue. If a certificate of exemption has issued in your matter, treat the date on it as the thing to act on and get advice about what has to be filed, and by when.

Settling, and the extra check if you do not have a lawyer

Most damages claims end in a settlement rather than a determination. Where the claimant is represented, that is a matter between the parties.

Where the claimant is not represented, the Commission applies a check. It states that if a claimant is not represented by an Australian legal practitioner, a claim for damages cannot be settled unless the proposed settlement is approved by the Commission. The insurer applies on behalf of both parties, and a member considers whether the settlement is just, fair and reasonable and within the range of likely damages assessments, and whether the claimant understands its nature and effect and is willing to accept it. The member may reject it, approve it as submitted, or approve an amended settlement the parties agree to along the way, and the Commission describes the decision as effectively binding.

That is a protection rather than a formality. A damages settlement is ordinarily final: it is assessed once, on the medical picture as it stands, and it is not reopened because an injury turns out to be worse than it looked.

Time limits, and why no number appears on this page

There is more than one clock in a motor accident claim. Reporting the accident, lodging a claim, asking an insurer for an internal review, disputing a decision at the Commission and commencing court proceedings after an exemption can each carry a period of its own. They are real, several are short, and missing one can end a claim that would otherwise have been good.

Which period binds you depends on the kind of claim, on the circumstances of the accident, and on the document you were given. That is why no day count is published here. Do not take a number of days from a website, including this one.

The periods are published in the Act and the Regulation, in the Commission’s rules and procedural directions, and usually in the letter the insurer sent you. If one of your dates is close, act on the document in your hand, and get advice before the date passes rather than after.

If you are holding a decision, a certificate or a notice from an insurer, the date on it is the starting point. Bring it, and the email or envelope it arrived in, to whoever reads the file.

Costs, and where to ask questions that are not the insurer

Legal costs in this scheme are regulated rather than open. What may be charged for a motor accident claim is restricted by the legislation, and the Commission publishes damages and costs calculators its members use to assess costs consistently. Whatever the arrangement, ask for it in writing before anything begins, and ask what happens to it if the claim does not succeed.

Many motor accident claims are resolved directly with the insurer and never involve a lawyer. A damages claim is the part of the scheme where that is least often true, because the two threshold findings and the question of fault all have to be dealt with before the money is reached. It is still worth knowing that free help exists and is not conditional on retaining anybody.

LawAccess NSW provides free legal information and referrals in New South Wales, and the NSW courts publish the free services available to people without a lawyer, including community legal centres and the Law Society of NSW pro bono scheme. The State Insurance Regulatory Authority regulates the CTP scheme and publishes its own material. None of them acts for you, and none replaces advice on your own claim from an Australian legal practitioner who has read your documents and your dates.

If you would rather describe the situation than read about it, tell us what has happened. The date of the accident, where the claim has got to, and the date on anything the insurer has sent you is enough to begin.

Official sources