Talking to the insurer
Once a claim is lodged, the calls, forms and requests start. This guide explains what each of them is for, and what happens afterwards to what you said.
General information, not legal advice. This page sets out how the law generally applies. It does not take account of your circumstances, and you should get advice about your own situation before acting on it. The official sources this page is written from are listed on it; where they differ from anything here, they are the authority.
The insurer decides liability, treatment and weekly payments, and it decides them on a file. What you say on the phone and what you sign on a form go into that file, and if the matter is later disputed the file is produced.
Before the first long conversation, write down what you actually remember and mark the parts you are unsure of. Then say you are unsure, rather than filling the gap.
Who you are speaking to
A claim under the New South Wales motor accident injury scheme is administered by a compulsory third party (CTP) insurer. The insurer decides whether liability is accepted, whether treatment and care is paid for, and what weekly payments are made. Those decisions come in writing, and most of them can be disputed.
An insurer has obligations under the scheme, and many of the people who work at one are helpful and straightforward. None of that makes them your adviser. They act for the insurer, the questions are asked for a reason, and the answers are recorded. That is not a criticism: one side does this every working day, the other is in the worst month of their life.
What the early conversations are for
The first contact usually comes by telephone soon after lodging. The insurer is confirming claim details, how the accident happened, what injuries you have and who is treating them, and what you earned beforehand. Each answer feeds a decision made later.
- Give the facts you know. Dates, the claim number, the road, the vehicles, who is treating you, where you work.
- Say so when you do not know. Speed, distance and right of way are argued about later, and an estimate offered on the phone can be read back as fact.
- Do not predict. How bad the injury will prove to be, and when you will be back at work, are not things you know yet.
- Correct mistakes in writing. If something is recorded wrongly, say so in an email and keep a copy.
- Keep your own note. The date and time of each call, who rang, and what was asked.
There is nothing improper in saying you are not well enough to talk at length today, or in asking for the questions in writing.
Recorded interviews and statements
You may be asked to take part in a recorded interview, or to sign a statement drawn from one. It is usually done by telephone, often early, and a recording or transcript goes onto the claim file. Nobody is on oath. It matters because it is often the only account of the accident made close to the time.
The Act imposes duties on a claimant in connection with a claim: one of the matters the Personal Injury Commission decides is whether a claimant has given a full and satisfactory explanation for non-compliance with a duty or for delay. So a request is not always only a request, and whether a particular one must be complied with is worth asking a lawyer about beforehand rather than afterwards.
What is always fair to ask for is time. An interview given while in pain, on strong medication, or days after a head injury is not a good way to produce an accurate record, and accuracy is the only thing the document is good for.
If English is not your first language, ask the insurer about an interpreter.
Forms, authorities and medical records
Alongside the calls come forms. Some are straightforward: claim details, bank details, certificates from your doctor. Others are authorities, by which you permit your practitioners, your employer or an agency to release records to the insurer.
An authority is worth reading slowly: what it covers, how far back it reaches and who it lets the insurer approach are all on the page. The Office of the Australian Information Commissioner describes express consent as consent given, for example, by signing a consent form, and says a health service provider may disclose your health information where you agree to it. Signing is the agreeing.
You may also be asked to attend a medical examination arranged by the insurer. That is part of how the scheme works out what an injury is and what it needs, rather than a sign that something has gone wrong.
If an authority looks wider than the claim, ask what is wanted and why before you sign it, and keep a copy.
What you say becomes the file
Describing a merit review, the Personal Injury Commission says the insurer is required to provide all documents or materials in its possession relevant to the proceedings, including all documents the claimant has previously provided to it. The file is produced whole.
In a medical dispute, the Commission says the assessment is made by a medical assessor, an independent specialist it appoints, who will usually examine the claimant and review the information provided by the parties. What you told the insurer early sits in that bundle beside what you told your doctor. None of that calls for perfection, but an account given once, quickly, is hard to move later.
When a conversation turns into a decision
A decision is not a phone call. Decisions on liability, on treatment and care, and on weekly payments are notified in writing with reasons. Keep those letters, and note the date each one reached you.
For most decisions the first step in disagreeing is asking the insurer to review its own decision, an internal review. If the answer does not change, the dispute goes to the Personal Injury Commission. The periods are short and generally run from the date on a document you were sent, which is why no day count is printed anywhere on this site. Take your dates off your own letters and have them checked.
Not all of this needs a lawyer. The State Insurance Regulatory Authority regulates the scheme and publishes guidance for people making claims. The Commission says it cannot give legal advice but can assist with the procedural aspects of an application, that its dispute resolution services are free, and that CTP Assist can provide information about the CTP Legal Advisory Service. LawAccess NSW gives legal information and referrals, and the Law Society of New South Wales runs a solicitor referral service.
When a decision goes against you sets out the dispute pathways in full.
What usually happens
The insurer makes contact
Usually by telephone, soon after lodging. Take the caller’s name and note the date.
You get your account straight
Write down what you remember and mark what you are unsure of.
The recorded interview
Ask what it covers and when it must happen. Ask for a copy. Read anything you sign.
Forms and authorities
Check what each authority covers and how far back it reaches. Keep copies.
Decisions arrive in writing
With reasons. Note the date each letter reached you.
If you disagree
Ask the insurer for an internal review first. If the answer does not change, the Commission decides.
Common questions
Do I have to do a recorded interview?
Do not assume either way. The Act imposes duties on a claimant, and whether a particular request must be complied with, and in what form, depends on what is being asked and why. There is nothing improper in asking for time, for the questions in writing, or for a copy of the recording. If you are unsure, ask a lawyer before the interview rather than afterwards.
Can I have someone with me, or an interpreter?
Ask the insurer. Nothing about the process requires you to do it alone. The Personal Injury Commission says it can arrange interpreters at no cost for its own proceedings and for medical assessments.
Should I send the insurer my medical records myself?
Usually you do not need to. The insurer will ordinarily ask you to sign an authority so that it can obtain them. Read what the authority covers, and if it looks wider than the claim, ask what is wanted and why.
Nothing seems to be happening. What can I do?
Put the question in writing so the request and its date are on the record. If you are waiting on an internal review, an insurer declining to conduct one, or failing to complete one when required to, is itself a situation in which a dispute can be lodged with the Personal Injury Commission.
Do I need a lawyer to deal with the insurer?
Often not. Many claims are dealt with directly with the insurer. It is worth asking early if the injuries are serious, if fault is in issue, if you have been asked for a recorded interview, or if a date is close. Costs in this scheme are regulated, so ask for them in writing before anything begins.
Related
Before the next call
Have these in front of you: the claim number, the date of the accident, every letter and email the insurer has sent with the date each arrived, the practitioners treating you, and your own note of what you remember and what you are unsure of.
Official sources
- Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (NSW)
- State Insurance Regulatory Authority (NSW)
- Personal Injury Commission — motor accidents disputes, 2017 scheme
- Personal Injury Commission — merit review dispute
- Personal Injury Commission — lodge a dispute
- Office of the Australian Information Commissioner — health information